Checking Several Approximation Claims for One Number
Checking Several Approximation Claims for One Number
Checks options that approximate one number to decimal places or significant figures, including trailing zeros.
- 212 bytes
- COMP mode
Worked examples
Example 1
The calculated mass of a standard sample is 0.004567 g. A to D below are claims by four students that approximate the same value. Decide whether each claim is correct; for a wrong claim, write the correct approximation to the stated precision.
A: 0.0046 g, to 2 significant figures.
B: 0.00457 g, to 3 significant figures.
C: 0.0045 g, to 4 decimal places.
D: 0.0046 g, to 3 decimal places.
Answer
Standard solution (without a calculator)
- Identify the place values: in 0.004567 the leading 0s are not significant figures. From the first non-zero digit 4 the significant figures are 4, 5, 6, 7; decimal places are counted from the first place after the point, including the two 0s. Every claim is rounded directly from the original number, never from the previous answer.
- Claim A: 2 significant figures keep 4 and 5; the next digit 6 rounds up, so 0.004567 ≈ 0.0046. The text also has 2 significant figures, so A is correct.
- Claim B: 3 significant figures keep 4, 5, 6; the next digit 7 rounds the last digit up to 7, giving 0.00457. It is written with 3 significant figures, so B is correct.
- Claim C: the 4th decimal place is 5 and the 5th is 6, so round up to 0.0046. The claim says 0.0045, so the value is wrong and C is wrong.
- Claim D: the 3rd decimal place is 4 and the next digit is 5, so round up to 0.005. The claim 0.0046 has the wrong value and also 4 decimal places, so D is wrong.
Example 2
The calculated time of a sprint is 12.346 s. A to D below record the same time to different precisions. Decide whether each is correct and correct any wrong approximation.
A: 12.35 s, to 2 decimal places.
B: 12.3 s, to 3 significant figures.
C: 12.34 s, to 4 significant figures.
D: 12 s, to the nearest integer.
Answer
Standard solution (without a calculator)
- Claim A: 2 decimal places keep the hundredths: 12.34, and the next digit 6 rounds up to 12.35. The text has 2 decimal places, so A is correct.
- Claim B: 3 significant figures count from the first digit 1 and keep 1, 2, 3. The next digit 4 does not round up, so the answer is 12.3 and B is correct.
- Claim C: 4 significant figures keep 1, 2, 3, 4; the next digit 6 rounds up, so the correct value is 12.35. The text 12.34 does have 4 significant figures, but its value is wrong, so C is wrong.
- Claim D: the nearest integer means 0 decimal places. The tenths digit of 12.346 is 3, which does not round up, so the answer is 12 and D is correct.
Example 3
The density of a liquid sample is calculated as 3.04958 g/cm³. Four students round it as shown in the options and state the precision they used: A, 3 decimal places; B, 4 significant figures; C, 4 decimal places; D, 3 significant figures. Which option is correct in both its value and the number of digits written?
Answer
Standard solution (without a calculator)
- Option A: to 3 decimal places keep 3.049; the next digit 5 rounds up and the 9 carries, giving 3.050. The option writes 3.050, with 3 decimal places including the final 0, so A is correct.
- Option B: to 4 significant figures keep 3, 0, 4, 9; the next digit 5 rounds up to 3.050. The option 3.05 has the same value, but it writes only 3 significant figures: the final 0 that shows the fourth figure is missing, so B is wrong.
- Option C: to 4 decimal places keep 3.0495; the next digit 8 rounds up to 3.0496. The option 3.0495 has the wrong value, so C is wrong.
- Option D: to 3 significant figures keep 3, 0, 4; the next digit 9 rounds up to 3.05. The option 3.04 only cuts off the later digits without rounding, so D is wrong.
- Choose: only A has both the right value and the right number of digits.
When to use it
Multiple-choice approximation questions give several options that round one number to a stated number of decimal places or significant figures and ask which are correct. A claim can fail in two ways: the value is wrong, or the digits written do not match the precision claimed (3.05 written for 4 significant figures has only 3). 002 takes the original number X once. For each option you enter its value A, the precision D it claims and the number of places B it actually writes; the program shows the correct approximation, with trailing zeros kept, and then 1 if value and writing both agree, otherwise 0.
What it is for
- One original number with several approximation claims (A to D), to decimal places, significant figures or the nearest integer
- The value and the number of digits actually written, including trailing zeros
- The original number may be a decimal, a fraction or a surd, e.g.
1÷π^(4or√(333
What you enter
- X: the original number, entered once; C: the number of options, preset to 4 — press EXE for four options
- A: the value of the option as written
- D: the precision claimed — 0 to 9 for decimal places, −1 to −10 for significant figures (minus with (−)); 0 is the nearest integer
- B: the number of places the option really writes, preset to |D| — press EXE only if it agrees, otherwise enter the real count
What it shows
- For each option, first the correct approximation: Fix keeps trailing zeros; Sci shows significant figures, e.g. 4.6E-03 means 0.0046
- Then 1 (value and written places both agree) or 0 (at least one does not)
- The final screen shows Y, the verdict of the last option; press AC
Check before use
- Use COMP. The example uses P1, which must be an empty program area with 212 bytes free. The program uses A, B, C, D, X, Y and M; note down any values you need to keep.
- X is the original number: a value, fraction or surd, e.g.
1÷π^(4or√(333. C is the number of options, a positive integer preset to 4; press EXE for four options. Options are processed in the order of the question; press AC when all are done. - D has one rule: decimal places are entered as 0 to 9, significant figures with a minus sign, −1 to −10. So 2 means 2 decimal places, −3 means 3 significant figures and 0 means the nearest integer. Use the (−) key for the minus. D does not mean “nearest 10 or 100”: there is no such mode.
- A is the value of the option as written. B is how many places of the kind chosen by D the option really writes, preset to |D|. Count the written text first: press EXE only if it agrees, otherwise enter the real count. Example: 3.05 claiming 4 significant figures needs D = −4 and B = 3; 3.0500 claiming 3 decimal places needs D = 3 and B = 4. This cannot be recovered from the number itself.
- Each option first shows the correct approximation and, after EXE, the verdict. 1 means the value and the written places both agree; 0 means at least one does not. Decimal places are shown with Fix, which keeps trailing zeros; significant figures are shown with Sci, so 1.00E+01 means 10.0, which keeps 3 significant figures.
- It checks the rounding of a single original number. It does not read the option’s wording, units or a whole interval, and it does not round down or work back to an error range. For a range of the original number use interval reasoning; one sample point never proves a result for all values. For a whole number ending in zeros, decide the significant figures from the question or scientific notation.
- Zero and negative numbers work, and an exact half is rounded away from zero (−2.5 to the integer gives −3). The significant figures of a written zero need a convention in the question; without one, describe the precision in decimal places. C, D and B must be entered as specified; to save space there is no input check, so after a wrong entry press AC and run again.
- The result screen holds at most 10 digits. If a decimal-place answer has more than 10 digits in all, it may switch to scientific notation and be rounded again, so the screen is then not the full answer. Enter ten or fewer significant figures directly, and enter a fraction or surd as the whole expression, not as a number you rounded yourself. Do not use it for very large values or for differences near the internal 15th digit; a difference in the last one or two digits may be treated as equal.
Checking access…